Cognitive
Structures and Dieting Habits:
An Interconnected Approach to Health.
Aug. 23
Summary: Cognitive structures, such as schemas and representations,
beliefs, and mindsets, are known to impact on information processing and
decision-making, but so are food nutrients. Recent research has shed
light on the impact of specific nutrients, such as sugar and certain
fats on our emotional and cognitive functions, including
decision-making, and behavior. Diets high in these substances have shown
to impact information processing and decision-making, leading to
suboptimal decisions in food consumption. However, diet alone cannot be
considered the sole determinant of an individual's dietary choices and
outcomes, particularly in terms of dieting success, optimal health, and
enhanced cognitive abilities. It is essential to consider other
influential factors that significantly impact eating habits and the
effectiveness of dieting efforts. Thoughts and mindsets surrounding
food, such as our relationship with eating and our attitudes towards
different types of diets, can heavily influence our dietary habits.
Additionally, social and economic factors, such as income and education
level, as well as one's commitment to self-care, have been found to
correlate with eating behaviors and the success of dieting endeavors.
Moreover, personal values and character traits play an important role in
fostering successful dieting and overall health. A strong foundation of
personal integrity, responsibility, trustworthiness, and honesty is
positively associated with dietary outcomes. Overall, the dynamic
interaction between an individual's cognitive frameworks and dietary
choices is vital in achieving successful dieting goals. Knowledge
structures empower individuals to make informed decisions, maintain
consistency in their dietary patterns, build positive relationships with
food, and stay motivated throughout their journey towards improving
their diet, health, and lifestyle. In that context, Cognitive Behavior
Therapy (CBT) emerges as an effective approach, enabling clients to
embrace healthier food mindsets, cultivate positive dietary habits, and
overcome obstacles on their path to improved diet, health, and
lifestyle.
High-sugar and high–fat diets
Food choices and lifetime decisions
Factors that influence food choices
Healthy eating habits and mindsets
Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT)
Cognitive distortions and restructuring
|
Fostering positive mindsets: a lifelong process
Shaping and reshaping mindsets
The benefits of positive thinking, and healthy living.
Factors associated with dieting and health
Values in successful dieting
|
In the field of cognitive science, cognitive structures have been
examined through a number of theoretical concepts, including schemas,
beliefs, mindsets, representations, and core values. These cognitive
constructs assume a crucial role in facilitating the assimilation and
interpretation of information, functioning as guiding principles in
shaping cognitive processes and behavioral responses, and exerting
considerable over our overall well-being, interpersonal interactions, as
well as future prospects.
Recently, a growing body of research has highlighted the significant
impact of dietary intake on cognitive frameworks and decision-making. It
has become increasingly apparent that the food we consume operates in a
manner akin to the acquisition of knowledge, exerting a profound
influence on cognitive processes, and choices related to food
consumption. This interplay between dietary intake and cognitive
structures has far-reaching implications on our lifestyle, and health.
High-sugar diets
According to Strang et al. (2017), dietary factors have the potential to
influence mood and cognitive processes. In their investigation,
participants were assigned to one of two breakfast conditions, which
were similar but differed substantially in terms of protein content.
Subsequently, participants were presented with a reward for their
participation. The reward consisted of a sum of money that was to be
divided into two separate amounts. However, the allocation of the money
was determined by the participant's partner, who was a research
assistant posing as a participant. In this scenario, the partner offered
the participant two Euros, while keeping eight Euros for himself. The
results revealed distinct choices made by participants based on the type
of breakfast they consumed. In such situations, those who consumed a
high-protein breakfast demonstrated greater tolerance towards an unfair
offer, whereas those who consumed a high-sugar breakfast displayed
reduced tolerance.
The investigation of the origins of this decision-making pattern,
subsequent to the consumption of a high-protein or high-carbohydrate
breakfast, involved the use of blood tests measuring the levels of
hormones and amino acids in the participants' blood. Specifically, the blood samples were analyzed for the presence of insulin, cortisol, adrenaline, and AGTH, in addition to the amino acids
tryptophan and tyrosine. Among these molecules, tyrosine was the most
noteworthy. This particular amino acid serves as a fundamental building
block for a brain protein, namely dopamine. As an integral part of the
brain's reward system, dopamine plays a critical role in facilitating
communication between neurons responsible for motivation and
risk-taking. The findings from the blood analyses demonstrated that
participants with elevated levels of tyrosine in their blood exhibited
greater willingness to accept unfair offers.
Strang's research team, in their comprehensive investigation, arrived at
the conclusion that dietary preferences hold the ability to
reshape the neurochemical makeup of the brain. As a result, this
intricate modulation of inter-neuronal communication stands as a key
factor, exerting significant influence on the decision-making mechanisms
and, subsequently, steering the course of behavioral outcomes. In other
words,
this implies that the food we consume has a tangible impact on cognitive
functions and the eventual behavioral consequences that follow.
High fat diets
Other studies have demonstrated that the consumption of high-fat meals
is linked to decision-making capabilities. For instance, Macchi, MacKew,
and Davis (2017) showed that the consumption of high-fat meals impairs
cognition, and decision-making, which subsequently led to impulsive responses
and unhealthy food choices. Similarly, Francis and Stevenson (2011)
conducted an investigation as to the effects of high-fat meals on
cognitive performance in young adults. Their findings revealed that the
consumption of meals containing high levels of fat led to cognitive
impairment, particularly in tasks that required attention, memory, and
decision-making skills.
Let’s note that the impact of high-fat diets on cognition and
decision-making is contingent upon the specific types of fats consumed.
Research has indicated that diets rich in saturated fats are associated
with adverse health outcomes, including impaired decision-making
abilities and an elevated risk of cognitive decline. Conversely, diets
abundant in healthy fats, such as omega-3 fatty acids, have beneficial
effects on brain function and cognitive performance. Omega-3 fatty acids
are commonly found in fatty fish (e.g., salmon and mackerel) as well as
certain plant sources like flaxseeds and walnuts. These fats possess
anti-inflammatory properties and contribute to the structural integrity
of brain cells (Jackson et al., 2012; Morris et al., 2015; Smith et al.,
2010).
The ramifications of high-sugar and high-fat diets encompass a broad
spectrum of outcomes. Particularly noteworthy is the influence of food
on decision-making and its significant impact on brain functions and
behavior in the short term (Ekstrand et al., 2021;
Gómez-Pinilla, 2008; Lugavere, 2020; Meyer,
2016; Micha et al., 2017). In the long term, diet rich in sugary and
fatty foods can trigger inflammation and oxidative stress that
contribute to cognitive impairments and even increasing the risk of
neurodegenerative diseases. The excessive intake of sugars and unhealthy
fats can damage internal organs, disrupting hormonal balance, and affecting appetite regulation,
mood stability, and emotional well-being. On a physiological
level, dietary choices can lead to weight gains, insulin resistance, and
cardiovascular problems, all of which have well-established connections
to cognitive decline and impaired brain function. Chronic exposure to
high-sugar and high-fat diets also impact gut health, altering the
gut-brain axis and potentially influencing mood, cognition, and behavior
through the intricate gut-brain communication pathways.
It has become evident that the implications of high-sugar and high-fat
diets, as well as diets deficient in essential nutrients like iron,
magnesium, vitamin B9, and B12, extend beyond short-term decision-making
processes and can exert profound and lasting effects on brain health and
overall well-being, including mental health (see
Gomez-Pinilla & Akbaraly, 2015; Jacka, Mykleturn, Berk, Bjelland, &
Tell, 2011 Sarris et al., 2015).
Consequently, the exploration of the intricate interconnections between
the brain, diet, and body remains a critical endeavor. By gaining a
comprehensive understanding of how nutrition contributes to optimal
health, cognitive capabilities, and social and emotional functioning
throughout the one's lifespan, we are poised to lay the foundation for
more informed dietary guidelines and targeted interventions that aim to
cultivate enduring well-being and elevate overall quality of life.
Food choices and lifetime decisions
Online studies (Roberts, 2017) involving participants from Canada and
the United States revealed that individuals who prefer a high-calorie
diet tend to make more short-term decisions compared to those who follow
a diet rich in proteins. Individuals with long-term goals and a
healthier diet tend to have more enduring objectives. Their aspirations
foster a culture of resilience, responsibility, and forward-thinking
that spans over several generations.
Essentially, the inclination towards long-term thinking not only shapes
how individuals envision their personal future, but also influences the
prospects of their descendants, encompassing their well-being and
success.
In a video interview by Cross (2020)
with an octogenarian woman, she was asked about her secret to living a
long and healthy life. She responded by saying: "Be good and kind, and
show gratitude to everyone." When questioned about her dietary habits,
she advised, "Consume food that is minimally processed and closer to its
natural state. Conversely, individuals who are more inclined towards
making short-term commitments hold the belief that life should be lived
one day at a time. This group is prone to experiencing health issues,
more likely to rent homes instead of buying, and less inclined to
prioritize the quality and benefits of their food choices.
In Cross's video, a man was asked about his perspective on food and
life. He confidently declared, "I have made up my mind that when my time
comes, I want to go out feeling content and satisfied." He proudly
embraced his gluttonous tendencies, seeking contentment and satisfaction
in the present moment. To him, food held more profound meaning than mere
sustenance; it was an experience that brought immediate joy, comfort,
and satisfaction. The pleasure he derived from indulging in food likely
served as a coping mechanism, likely influenced by the passing of a
young brother whom he admired. This event had a profound impact on his
decision-making, leading him to prioritize the joy of indulging in his
passions without reservation, rather than focusing on long-term planning
and delayed gratification.
Factors that influence food choices
Another online survey designed to assess people's level of dietary
knowledge, participants responded to a questionnaire titled: "What do I
know about healthy food and diet?" Items consisted of open-ended
questions (e.g., What are the best foods for one's health?) and
multiple-choice questions (e.g., Of the following items, what
contributes most to weight-gain?). Additionally, demographic information
was collected, including age, gender, and socioeconomic status, overall
health, and cultural background.
The primary focus of the survey was to investigate how participants'
culture, as well as other factors influences their diet and health.
These factors encompassed family, education, profession, economic
standing, environmental influence, nutritional knowledge, and eating
habits. To analyze these relationships, a factor analysis with multiple
regressions was conducted, enabling the identification of distinct
groups of participants (factors) within different categories related to
participants’ diet and health outcomes.
The findings revealed the participants' beliefs about diet and eating
habits can be condensed into several factor dimensions, which predicted
their food consumption patterns. One group of participants exhibited
dietary choices influenced by their religious and philosophical beliefs.
However, variations in food choices and eating habits were observed even
within different religious groups, highlighting the complexity of
individual preferences and cultural influences. Moreover, individuals'
schedules played a role in shaping their food habits, with those engaged
in frequent travel tending to rely on restaurant meals, while
individuals with demanding work schedules often resorted to ordering
food to be brought to work. Furthermore, income level emerged as a
determining factor in the quality of food consumed. Participants with
higher income were more inclined to opt for healthy meals from
high-quality restaurants, while, lower-income individuals tended to rely
on fast-food establishments, possibly due to financial constraints and
the convenience of such options.
The findings of this survey-based study provided insight into a complex
web of factors that contribute to individuals' food consumption patterns
and its consequent impact on lifestyle and health. The identified
predictors (e.g., beliefs, religion, and cultural values) not only
influence participants' dietary choices but also have significant
implications for their overall health and well-being. Of particular
significance is the observation that participants’ knowledge, beliefs
and attitudes toward food. Those who held favorable beliefs regarding
the importance of nutritious eating were more prone to making mindful
food selections, thereby contributing to enhanced health results and an
extended lifespan.
Healthy eating and mindsets
Several studies have shown that people’s mindsets have an impact on food
choices and health (Carpenter, 2022; Grave & Calugi, 2020; Tribole &
Resch, 2017). A mindset refers to the established attitudes, beliefs,
and perspectives that shape an individual's way of thinking and
interpreting the world. It encompasses the mental frameworks and thought
patterns that influence a person's behavior, decision-making, and
reactions to various situations. For instance, the mindsets of healthy
individuals who maintain a balance and varied diet differ from those who
engage in mindless eating or have no restrictions on food choices and
diet. Figure 1 presents some key characteristics or mindsets related to
healthy eating habits.
Figure 1. Mindsets related to healthy eating
Awareness:
Healthy eating starts with awareness. This includes knowing the
nutritional content of different foods, how specific foods affect
the body’s organs, and being conscious of the impact of dietary
choices on overall health.
Balance:
Balance is important for obtaining a broad spectrum of nutrients.
Consuming a variety of foods ensures that the body receives
essential vitamins, minerals, and other micronutrients necessary for
good health.
Moderation:
Moderation involves practicing portion control and avoiding extremes
in food consumption. Healthy individuals listen to their body's
hunger and fullness cues, eating until they are satisfied rather
than stuffing themselves.
Flexibility:
Healthy individuals have a flexible approach to food and understand
that occasional indulgences can be integrated into a well-rounded
lifestyle without compromising overall health and well-being.
Planning and preparation:
Healthy individuals plan their meals in advance and make thoughtful
choices while grocery shopping. They prioritize home-cooked meals
and engage in meal prepping, which give them a better control over
ingredient selection and portion sizes.
Mindful eating:
Practicing mindful eating is a common habit among healthy
individuals. This involves focusing on the present moment while
eating. They take the time to savor their food, chew it thoroughly,
and appreciate each bite.
Relationship with food:
Healthy individuals maintain a positive and balanced relationship
with food. They view food as nourishment for their body and mind,
emphasizing pleasure and enjoyment while also considering its
nutritional value.
Whole Foods:
Favoring whole, unprocessed foods is a characteristic of healthy
eating. Whole foods are typically rich in nutrients and have fewer
added sugars, salt, and unhealthy fats.
Nutrient density:
Healthy eating prioritizes nutrient-dense foods, which are foods
that provide a high concentration of essential nutrients relative to
their calorie content. Foods like vegetables, fruits, nuts, and lean
proteins are examples of nutrient-dense choices.
Consistency:
Healthy individuals understand that maintaining a balanced diet is a
long-term commitment to their health. They adopt sustainable eating
habits rather than resorting to short-term fad diets or extreme
restrictions.
Dweck (2006) introduced a broader concept known as a growth mindset.
In the context of promoting healthy eating and overall well-being, a
growth mindset entails the belief that one's dietary habits and health
can be enhanced through active learning, dedicated effort, and adaptable
strategies. Individuals embracing a growth mindset with regards to
health are receptive to exploring novel foods, experimenting with
diverse dietary approaches, and are more eager to derive lessons from both
successes and errors. Rather than considering setbacks as indications of
permanent failure, they perceive them as opportunities for learning and
recalibrating their approach. This mindset fosters a continuous pursuit
of knowledge about nutrition, the exploration of healthier food
alternatives, and the cultivation of a positive outlook towards making
enduring lifestyle adjustments to enhance overall health.
Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT)
Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) stands as a prominent method amidst
various approaches aimed at bolstering clients' commitment to
maintaining healthy dietary routines. CBT harnesses cognitive
techniques, empowering individuals to confront and counteract
detrimental thoughts, as well as persuasive advertising, by presenting
them with more compelling alternatives. Numerous studies have provided
compelling evidence of the potency of cognitive therapy in aiding
individuals in surmounting a wide spectrum of psychological challenges,
encompassing conditions like eating disorders.
Stahre et al. (2007) reported that Cognitive Therapy is effective in
treating eating disorders and facilitating weight loss. In their study
of 54 women, participants who enrolled in a cognitive therapy weight
loss program for just 10 sessions lost an average of nearly 19 pounds,
compared with an average of just 1.5 points for study participants who
received advice about exercise and other weight-loss behaviors but did
not learn essential cognitive therapy techniques. Furthermore, a year
and a half after the end of the program the participants in the
cognitive therapy group maintained most of their weight loss keeping off
an average of 13 pounds, whereas the no-cognitive therapy group gained
weight, ending up heavier than they were before the study began.
Cognitive restructuring
Cognitive restructuring is a therapeutic technique that entails the
identification and evaluation of negative and automatic thoughts, which
frequently exhibit distortions and irrationality, with the objective of
substituting them with positive and rational thoughts (Beck et al.,
2020; Dweck, 2006; Hofmann et al., 2012). By challenging and replacing
negative thoughts associated with food, individuals have the potential
to cultivate a healthier relationship with food, foster positive dietary
behaviors, and improve their overall well-being. The following examples
illustrate the transformation of negative food-related thoughts into
positive ones.
Negative |
Positive |
I am hungry, I have to eat. |
I am hungry. It’s too early to eat, so I’ll wait till lunch. |
I am upset. I need to eat. |
I'm upset. Eating now will only make me feel worse. I'll find a
way to calm down instead. |
It won’t matter if I at this unplanned food because its’ only a
small piece. |
It does matter. If I eat this unplanned food, I'll be
reinforcing my impulsive eating habits. |
Uh-oh, I might lose control and eat too much at the party |
I know exactly what to do if I'm tempted. I'll have a healthy
eating life plan in place to help me stay on track. |
I have to eat this unplanned food my hostess is offering.
|
I will politely say, “no, thanks,” I’m entitled to stick up for
myself, even if my hostess is momentarily disappointed.
|
I can eat on the fly. |
I don’t have to eat on the go. I can take the time I need to buy
food, prepared it, and eat it slowing, enjoying every bite.
|
There are “good” foods” and “bad” foods. I should never have bad
food. |
I can eat any favorite food, in a reasonable portion, ounce in a
while. |
I just cheated on my diet. I’ve blown it. I may as well continue
eating whatever. |
I made a mistake, but that doesn't mean I've ruined my diet. I
can start again right now and get back on track. |
This eating plan is too hard. I’m giving up.
|
I feel it’s hard right now, but this feeling is temporary. I’ll
go distract myself and in a few minutes, I’ll be really glad I
did. |
Cognitive distortions
Cognitive distortions play a privotal role in shaping an individual's
perception of reality, ultimately giving rise to flawed convictions and
unproductive actions. These distortions encompass patterns of thought
that lack rationality and precision, exerting the potential to sway an
individual's feelings, thoughts, and conduct (Leahy, 2017). In the field
of dietary practices, cognitive distortions have a substantial influence
over an individual's selection of food, eating routines, and their
overall connection with nourishment. Figure 2 provides several
illustrations of cognitive distortions in the context of food choices
and diet.
Cognitive restructuring serves as a technique within Cognitive
Behavioral Therapy (CBT) aimed at assisting individuals in recognizing
and altering their irrational thought patterns, beliefs, and cognitive
distortions. It is imperative for individuals to develop an awareness of
their negative thoughts intertwined with cognitive distortions. Yet,
through the process of acknowledging and questioning cognitive
distortions like black-and-white thinking, emotional reasoning, and
labeling, individuals can actively nurture more optimistic and
productive thoughts. This transformation paves the way for fostering a
healthier and more positive connection with food (Fairburn, Cooper &
Shafran, 2003).
Figure 2: Cognitive Distortions
All-or-Nothing Thinking:
This distortion involves seeing things in black and white, without
considering any shades of gray. It often leads to rigid thinking
patterns. Example: "I ate a piece of cake at a party, so my diet is
ruined. I might as well give up and eat whatever I want for the rest
of the day."
Overgeneralization:
This distortion involves making broad conclusions based on isolated
incidents or limited evidence. Example: "I tried a new diet and it
didn't work for me. All diets are ineffective, so there's no point
in trying again."
Mental Filtering:
This distortion involves focusing only on the negative aspects of a
situation while ignoring any positive aspects. Example: "I had a
healthy breakfast and lunch, but I ate a small dessert in the
evening. I failed to stick to my diet and ruined the progress I've
made."
Emotional Reasoning:
This distortion involves assuming that emotions reflect the
truth or reality. Example: "I feel guilty about eating a
slice of pizza, so I must have done something wrong. I should punish
myself by skipping lunch tomorrow."
Catastrophizing:
I refer to it as “doomsday” thinking. This distortion involves
exaggerating the negative consequences of a situation. Example: "If
I eat this cookie, I'll gain so much weight that I'll never be able
to lose it. I'll end up overweight and unhealthy forever."
Labeling:
This distortion involves applying extreme judgmental labels to
oneself based on behavior. Example: "I ate a high-calorie meal
today; I'm such a failure. I'm always going to be overweight."
Mind Reading:
This distortion involves assuming you know what others are thinking,
often assuming negative judgments. Example: "If I order a salad
instead of a burger, my friends will think I'm boring or obsessed
with my weight."
Discounting the Positive:
This distortion involves dismissing or devaluing positive
experiences or accomplishments. Example: "Yes, I lost a few pounds
this week, but it was probably just water weight. It doesn't really
count."
In the context of dieting, cognitive distortions also emerge in the form
of "I must" and "I should" statements, characterized by the imposition
of rigid and unrealistic expectations upon oneself. Illustrative
instances of "I must" statements are exemplified by the following: "I
must consistently adhere to my dieting regimen" or "I must never make
mistakes." Conversely, an example of an "I should" statement would be:
"I should abstain from consuming carbohydrates. Any lapse would signify
a lack of willpower and self-discipline." Such thought patterns have the
potential to evoke feelings of inadequacy, frustration,
self-questioning, and unease. Therefore, it helps to challenge these
distortions by thoroughly examining the evidence both supporting and
contradicting them, and subsequently substituting them with more
pragmatic and flexible convictions, or mindsets.
Fostering positive mindsets
Mindsets, which encompass overall attitudes, beliefs, and perspectives,
have a significant role in the context of healthy dieting. Mindsets can
trigger emotions, inspire confidence, and shape behaviors related to the
adoption and maintenance of a healthy lifestyle. By cultivating positive
mindsets and practicing self-awareness (e.g., paying attention to
sensory experiences, thoughts and foods), individuals can empower
themselves to make healthier choices, enhance their emotional
well-being, and achieve greater success in their quest for a balanced
and nourishing diet (see Warren, Smith & Ashwell, 2017; Bahl, Milne &
Chan, 2013; Thomas, Burnette, & Hoy, 2019).
Beck’s (1976) cognitive-behavioral model posits that our thoughts, specific ideas, cognitions, or mental processes that occur in our
minds have a significant impact on our behavior. These thoughts and
mindsets collectively shape how we interpret situations, make decisions,
and consequently, guide our actions. A study conducted by Cho et al.
(2018) revealed that individuals who practiced positive self-talk
exhibited improved self-control and displayed a greater propensity for
selecting nutritious food options over unhealthy alternatives.
Moreover, cultivating self-awareness, a fundamental aspect of mindset
development, has been shown to contribute to making improved dietary
choices. Several studies have shown that individuals with a positive
mindset towards healthy eating exhibit greater adherence to nutritious
dietary practices (Deshpande et al., 2009; Dweck, 2007; Pelletier et
al., 2004; Werthmann, Jansen & Roefs, 2016). In essence, mindsets assume
a pivotal role in upholding a healthy way of life. Constructive thoughts
or positive affirmations substantially bolster motivation,
self-efficacy, and adherence to health-promoting behavioral routines.
Shaping and reshaping mindsets, a lifelong process
In contemporary technological societies, as individuals, we are
continuously immersed in a plethora of information and a wide range of
about various aspects of life, including the concept of maintaining a
healthy diet. Moreover, the emergence of advancing scientific research,
alongside the prevalence of social media and online platforms,
continually expose individuals (us) to novel perspectives that challenge
their beliefs and attitudes. As a result, the process of shaping and
reshaping our thoughts becomes an ongoing journey that requires
steadfast dedication to intellectual curiosity, introspection, and a
readiness to adopt alternative modes of thinking.
The pursuit of better health has become a paramount concern for most
individuals, and the maintenance of adaptive eating habits is
consistently ranked high on their lifelong wellness agenda. However,
there are occasions when our thoughts veer off course, particularly
before we engage in a meal. Regardless of our level of awareness,
pre-meal thoughts invariably arise, ranging from simple statements like
"I'll indulge in some undesirable food” and “I’ll resume my dietary
regimen tomorrow." To counteract these wayward thoughts, it is advisable
to employ the following mantra: My Healthy Eating Life Plan promotes
health, energy, longevity and prosperity. This mantra can be summarized
by the acronym HELP Oh HELP. This acronym represents my commitment
to A Healthy Eating Life Plan for the
Olympic of Health, Energy, Longevity and
Prosperity.
A Healthy Eating Life Plan encompasses a comprehensive approach
to nutrition that goes beyond merely choosing the right foods. It
embodies specific mindsets and a commitment to nourishing the body for
long-term well-being. Such a plan is designed to provide not only
physical health benefits, but also plays a crucial role in securing
optimal health, longevity and prosperity throughout one’s life. To
cultivate a healthy eating life plan, it is essential to engage in a
comprehensive cognitive approach that encompasses a range of thoughts
and mindsets, cognitive strategies and behavioral methods. Implementing
such an approach is more likely to foster a transformative environment
that encourages the exploration and acceptance of diverse perspectives.
Figure 3 present a seven-step program that aims to reshape thoughts
mindsets and thoughts for personal and collective growth.
Figure 3: Seven-Step Program to reshape thoughts and mindsets
Specific trigger:
State what triggered the thought and the emotions associated with
the automatic thought. Keep a diary. Write down the time and place,
the circumstances. Example: The trigger is a plate of cookies at
a social gathering. The automatic thought is, "If I don't eat these
cookies, I will feel deprived and unsatisfied."
Restate the thought:
Change any question into a theory or prediction. State the thought
in specific terms, then restate. Example: "These feelings mean
that I have a desire for sweets, but it doesn't mean I am incapable
of sticking to a healthy diet.”
Cognitive distortion:
Determine the underlying distortion. The underlying cognitive
distortion is identified as catastrophizing. The individual may
think, "If I eat the cookies, it will be a complete disaster, and I
will never be able to follow a healthy diet."
Probability of happening:
State the probability of the thought by using a scale from 0-100%.
In this case, the individual determines that the probability of
the feared disaster occurring is relatively low, about 20%.
My evidence:
Ask yourself. Is what I think or did acceptable? The evidence that I
am using to support the automatic support has led me to conclude the
following. Example: I recall times when he or she has followed a
healthy diet and experienced increased energy levels and improved
mood. This evidence supports the idea that a healthy diet can be
satisfying and beneficial.
Alternative hypothesis:
There are several alternative hypotheses to consider regarding the
unwanted food and a healthy diet. The probability of each
alternative hypothesis being true is rated from 0 to 100%.
Hypothesis 1: If I incorporate a variety of nutritious foods into my
diet and allow myself occasional treats in moderation, I can still
enjoy my meals while maintaining a healthy lifestyle (probability:
80%).
Hypothesis 2: By adjusting specific food related mindsets and
focusing on the positive aspects of a healthy diet, such as the
long-term health benefits and improved self-confidence, I can
overcome any feelings of deprivation (probability: 70%).
Hypothesis 3: Exploring new recipes and cooking techniques can make
my healthy meals more interesting and satisfying, reducing the
likelihood of feeling unsatisfied (probability: 60%).
Reformulate the new thought, theory:
The new thought is formulated by the alternative hypothesis.
Example: I believe that by incorporating a variety of nutritious
foods, allowing occasional treats in moderation, re-adjusting
relevant mindsets, and exploring new recipes, I can have a positive
and enjoyable experience with food choices. Next time, I will remind
myself of the evidence supporting the benefits of a healthy diet,
explore new recipes to keep my meals exciting, and focus on the
long-term health outcomes to overcome any feelings of deprivation."
The benefits of positive thinking, and healthy living.
There are numerous proverbs emphasizing the importance of a positive
attitude towards foods. For instance, one adage asserts, "You are what
you eat,’ while another highlights the idea of “Eating to live, not
living to eat." Quotations further reinforce the theme of positive
thinking, such as Virginia Woolf's assertion that "Eating well is a form
of self-respect." and the notion that "One cannot think well, love well,
sleep well, if one has not dined well." Undoubtedly, the power of
positive thinking, thoughts, and mindsets plays a significant role in
embracing and maintaining a healthy diet. By actively harnessing the
strength of our minds to make positive choices regarding our eating
habits, we lay the foundation for a nourishing and healthy lifestyle.
The benefits of a healthy diet extend well beyond physical well-being,
exerting a profound impact on our emotional and mental well-being. First
and foremost, consuming a well-balanced diet has innumerable benefits.
It contributes significantly to the enhancement of our health and
cognitive functions. A wholesome and nourishing diet provides the brain
with essential nutrients required for optimal performance, thereby
resulting in heightened cognitive capacities, including enhanced memory,
focus, and reasoning. Through the provision of optimal nourishment to
our brains, a balanced diet equips us with the ability to think with
greater clarity, make well-considered choices, and excel in our daily
endeavours.
A healthy diet also assumes a critical function in facilitating the
promotion of quality sleep, an indispensable element for optimal
emotional and mental well-being. Research has established a strong
correlation between disrupted sleep patterns and an augmented
susceptibility to the development of mental health disorders, including
anxiety and depression. In contrast, a well-balanced diet that fosters a
restful night's sleep can substantially contribute to enhanced mood
regulation, superior stress coping mechanisms, and heightened cognitive
capabilities (Baglioni et al., 2011; Grandner et al., 2014)).
Engaging in mindful eating practices and sharing nutritious meals with
family, co-workers, and friends can strengthen social connections.
Social interactions provide a support system and foster a sense of
community that extends beyond the dining table. When we engage in
mindful eating and share nutritious meals with others, we create an
environment that encourages open communication, empathy, and
understanding. Moreover, these positive relationships contribute to our
overall emotional well-being, creating a support system and a sense of
community that is important not only for mental health but also help to
cultivate a sense of unity and togetherness, strengthening the fabric of
social networks.
When examining the essential components of well-being, it
becomes crucial to recognize the profound impact of positivism,
optimistic thinking, and empowering attitudes on health concerns related
to aging and longevity. Empirical studies have provided substantial
evidence that cultivating a positive perspective contributes to
extending one's lifespan and mitigating the vulnerabilities linked to
the aging process (Chida & Steptoe, 2008; Tindle, Chang, Kuller et al.,
2009). The adoption of an affirmative mindset has been associated with
an array of advantageous health outcomes, including the mitigation of
stress levels, augmentation of immune functionality, and overall
enhancement of well-being.
Factors related to dieting and health
Further to our online studies, a significant number of respondents
expressed a desire to improve their health. The percentage of agreement
varied across age groups with older groups more incline in wanting
improve both their health and lifestyle. This is supported by various
studies and surveys. One example is a survey conducted by Neilsen (2015)
which found that globally, 88% of respondents considered their overall
well-being, including their mental and physical health, to be important.
Furthermore, Neilsen had examined the health goals of 2,000 participants
aged 18-91 years, and reported that 75% of the participants expressed a
desire to improve their health and fitness.
Many adults who responded to our survey were on a diet or had followed
one. Some for weight management, while others had specific dietary
restrictions or preferences based on their health conditions, ethical
beliefs, or religious practices. Importantly, it was found that the
success rate of various diets has shown to differ based on a number of
determinant factors. The diet was a factor but so were other factors
such as people’s socioeconomic status, cognitive abilities, education,
life-long learning, collaboration and diversity, mental health and
self-efficacy. A review of the literature has shown to that many of
these factors contributed to longevity (See section on Diet, Aging, and
Longevity). Figure 4 presents some these factors that facilitate with
healthy dieting, and health.
Intellectual abilities have emerged as a pivotal factor in shaping our
dietary inclinations and actions. The spectrum of intelligence,
encompassing diverse cognitive capacities, profoundly shapes the
mechanisms behind food choices and self-discipline, both pivotal in
upholding a nourishing diet. Contemporary research underscores that
those endowed with greater cognitive acumen exhibit heightened mastery
over self-regulation, displaying a propensity for enduring
foresight—attributes pivotal in fostering the embrace of
health-conscious eating habits (Baym & Corbet, 2009).
Values and successful dieting
Personal values can act as powerful motivators that contribute to
healthy dieting by shaping individuals' attitudes, knowledge, goal
setting, and behaviors related to food choices. Key values that
influence successful dieting include integrity and ethical
responsibility, authenticity, transparency, compassion, trustworthiness,
and honesty. Figure 4 lists some of these values associated with
successful dieting, health and lifestyle-choices (see references for a
more exhaustive list of values impacting successful healthy eating life
habits (Brug, 2008; Hansen & Thomsen, 2018; Lee et al., 2014).
Figure 4: Values associated with dieting
Integrity and Ethical Responsibility:
Having integrity means adhering to a set of moral principles and
being honest with oneself and others. In the context of dieting,
this value can translate into being committed to following a healthy
eating plan and avoiding deceptive practices such as fad diets or
using harmful substances.
Authenticity:
Being authentic involves being true to oneself and embracing one's
unique identity. In the context of dieting and lifestyle,
authenticity means finding a way of eating and exercising that
resonates with one's individual preferences, goals, and values. It
encourages individuals to avoid overly comparing themselves to
others and instead focus on what truly works for them, fostering a
sustainable and enjoyable approach to health.
Transparency:
Transparency refers to being open, honest, and forthcoming. In the
context of dieting and health, transparency can be associated with
being honest about one's habits, challenges, and progress. It
involves sharing relevant information with healthcare professionals,
seeking support when needed, and being open to feedback and
guidance. Transparency can facilitate accountability and promote a
deeper understanding of one's health journey.
Compassion:
Compassion entails showing kindness, empathy, and understanding
towards oneself and others. In the context of dieting and lifestyle,
compassion involves treating oneself with self-compassion and
avoiding harsh self-judgment. It also extends to supporting and
encouraging others in their health goals, creating a positive and
supportive environment that promotes overall well-being.
Honesty:
Honesty as a personal value can facilitate successful dieting by
promoting self-reflection and accountability. Being honest with
oneself about dietary habits, preferences, and challenges allows
individuals to identify areas for improvement and develop effective
strategies for achieving their health goals.
Trustworthiness:
Trustworthiness involves being reliable, dependable, and consistent.
When it comes to dieting and lifestyle, being trustworthy means
keeping commitments made to oneself, such as sticking to a meal plan
or exercise routine. It also involves building trust with others by
being consistent in one's actions and maintaining open
communication.
Collaboration:
Collaborative environments and social support have been associated
with better adherence to healthy eating habits. Studies have shown
that engaging in collaborative efforts, such as group interventions
or supportive social networks, can positively influence dietary
behaviors and help sustain healthy eating patterns.
An interactional model for optimizing dieting and health
In conclusion, the realm of food choices and adherence to diets is an
intricate and multifaceted phenomenon that extends far beyond the mere
adoption of specific dietary plans or routines. While particular foods
and nutrients have a substantial sway over our decision-making and
behaviors, it is imperative to acknowledge the pivotal roles played by
our cognitive structures. The interplay between the choices we make in
sustenance and the intricate web of cognitive frameworks is significant,
yet it is imperative to underscore that a multitude of other factors
also exert their influence. Notably, social and economic dimensions, as
well as the level of commitment to self-care, have a considerable impact
on our dietary patterns and the success of our dieting endeavors.
Greater alignment with these foods and health related dimensions, the
greater likelihood a person’s eating habits being conducive to a healthy
lifestyle. Thus, deeper insights into these multi-faceted factors can
lead to an enhanced understanding of the determinants of dietary choices
and outcomes. Understanding and addressing these diverse influences are
crucial in optimizing our health and fostering sustainable lifestyle
changes. With a more comprehensive understanding of these dynamics,
researchers and health professionals can develop more effective
approaches to support individuals in achieving their dietary goals and
sustaining healthier lifestyles. |
References
Baglioni, C., Battagliese, G., Feige, B., et al. (2211). Insomnia as a
predictor of depression: a meta-analytic evaluation of longitudinal
epidemiological studies. Journal of Affective Disorders, 135(1-3):10-19.
DOI:
10.1016/j.jad.2011.01.011
Bahl, S., Milne, G. R., & Chan, F. (2013). Mindfulness: A long-term
solution for mindless eating by college students. Journal of Public
Policy & Marketing, 32(2), 173-184.
DOI:10.1509/jppm.11.008
Baym, C. L.,
& Corbett, B. A. (2009). Identification of early risk factors for
obesity. Child Development Perspectives, 3(1), 40-44.
DOI:
10.1111/j.1750-8606.2008.00075.
Beck,
A. T. (1976). Cognitive therapy and the emotional disorders.
International Universities Press.
Beck,
J. S. (2020). Cognitive Behavior Therapy: Basics and Beyond (3rd
ed.). The Guildford Press.
Brug, J. (2008). Determinants of healthy eating: motivation, abilities
and environmental opportunities. Family Practice, 25(1), i50-i55.
https://doi.org/10.1093/fampra/cmn063
Chida,
Y., & Steptoe, A. P. (2008). Positive psychological well-being and
mortality: a quantitative review of prospective observational studies. Psychosomatic Medicine, 70(7):741-56.
DOI:
10.1097/PSY.0b013e31818105ba
Cho
H, Ryu S, Noh J, Lee J. (2016) The Effectiveness of Daily Mindful
Breathing Practices on Test Anxiety of Students. PLoS ONE 11(10),
1-10 DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0164822
Cross, J.
(2010). Fat, Sick & Nearly Dead [Documentary film].
Retrieved from
https://www.youtube.com/
Darmon, N.,
& Drewnowski, A. (2008). Does social class predict diet quality?
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 87(5):1107-17.
DOI:
10.1093/ajcn/87.5.1107.
Deshpande, S., Basil, M. D., & Basil, D. Z. (2009).
Factors
influencing healthy eating habits among college students: an application
of the health belief model. Health Marketing Quarterly, 26(2),
145-163.
https://doi.org/10.1080/07359680802619834
Dweck,
C. S. (2006). Mindset: The new psychology of success. Random
House.
Ekstrand, B., Scheers, N., Rasmussen, M. K., Young, J. F., Ross, A. B.,
& Landberg, R. Brain foods - the role of diet in brain performance and
health. Nutr Rev, 79(6):693-708.
DOI:10.1093/nutrit/nuaa091
Fairburn, C. G., Cooper, Z., & Shafran, R. (2003). Cognitive behaviour
therapy for eating disorders: a "transdiagnostic" theory and treatment.
Behaviour Research and Therapy, 41(5), 509-528.
DOI:
10.1016/s0005-7967(02)00088-8
Francis, H. M., & Stevenson, R. J. (2011). Higher reported saturated fat
and refined sugar intake is associated with reduced hippocampal-dependent
memory and sensitivity to interoceptive signals.
Behavioral Neuroscience, 125(6), 943–955.
https://doi.org/10.1037/a0025998
Gómez-Pinilla, F. (2008). Brain foods: the effects of nutrients on brain
function. Nat Rev Neurosci., 9(7):568-78.
doi: 10.1038/nrn2421.
Gómez-Pinilla, F,, & Tyagi, E. (2013). Diet and cognition: interplay
between cell metabolism and neuronal plasticity. Curr Opin Clin Nutr
Metab Care. 16(6):726-33.
doi: 10.1097/MCO.0b013e328365aae3.
Giskes, K., van Lenthe, F., Avendano-Pabon, M., & Brug, J, (2011). A
systematic review of environmental factors and obesogenic dietary
intakes among adults: are we getting closer to understanding obesogenic
environments?
Obesity Review,12(5). DOI:10.1111/j.1467-789X.2010.00769.x
Grandner, M. A., Jackson, N., Gerstner, J. R., Knutson K. L. (2014).
Sleep symptoms associated with intake of specific dietary nutrients.
Journal of Sleep Research. 23(1):22-34.
https://doi.org/10.1111/jsr.12084
Hansen, T., & Thomsen, T. U. (2018). The influence of consumers’
interest in healthy eating, definitions of healthy eating, and personal
values on perceived dietary quality. Food Policy, 80, 55-67.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodpol.2018.09.002
Hofmann, S. G., Asnaani, A., Vonk, I. J., Sawyer, A. T., & Fang, A.
(2012). The efficacy of cognitive behavioral therapy: A review of
meta-analyses. Cognitive therapy and research, 36(5), 427-440.
DOI:
10.1007/s10608-012-9476-1
Jackson, P. A., Reay, J. L., Scholey, A. B., & Kennedy, D. O. (2012).
DHA-rich oil modulates the cerebral haemodynamic response to cognitive
tasks in healthy young adults: a near IR spectroscopy pilot study.
British Journal of Nutrition,
107(8), 1093-8. DOI:
10.1017/S0007114511004041
Jacka. F. N,, Mykletun. A,, Berk, M., Bjelland, I., & Tell, G. S.
(2011). The association between habitual diet quality and the common
mental disorders in community-dwelling adults: the Hordaland Health
study. Psychosom Med., 73(6):483-90.
doi: 10.1097/PSY.0b013e318222831a.
Leahy, R. L. (2017). Cognitive Therapy Techniques: A Practitioner's
Guide (2nd ed.). The Guilford Press.
Lee,
P., Lusk, K., Misosa, M., & Oey, I. (2014). The role of personal values
in Chinese consumers’ food consumption decisions. A case study of
healthy drinks. Appetite, 73, 95-104. DOI:10.1016/j.appet.2013.11.001
Lugavere, M. (2020). The genius life: heal your mind, strengthen your
body, and become extraordinary. Harper Wave.
Macchi, R., MacKew, L., & Davis, C. (2017). Is decision-making ability
related to food choice and facets of eating behaviour in adolescents?
Appetite, 116(1), 442-455.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.appet.2017.05.031
Meyer, E. (2016). The mind-gut connection: How the hidden
conversation within our bodies impacts our mood, our choices, and our
overall Health. Harper Wave.
Micha., R., Peñalvo, J. L. , Cudhea, F., Imamura, F., Rehm, C. D., &
Mozaffarian, D. (2017). Association Between Dietary Factors and
Mortality From Heart Disease, Stroke, and Type 2 Diabetes in the United
States. JAMA, 317(9), 912-924.
DOI:
10.1001/jama.2017.0947
Morris, M. C., Tangney, C. C., Wang, Y., Sacks, F. M., Barnes, L. L.,
Bennett, D. A., & Aggawal, N. T. (2015). MIND diet slows cognitive
decline with aging. Alzheimer’s & Dementia Journal, 11(9),
1015-22.
DOI:
10.1016/j.jalz.2015.04.011
Nielsen Survey (2015). Global survey: Consumers' quest for healthier
lifestyles Intensifies. Journal of Health Psychology, 21(3),
429-439.
Pelletier, L. G., Dion, S. C., Slovinec-D'Angelo, M. et al.
(2004). Why do you regulate what you eat? Relationships between forms of
regulation, eating behaviors, sustained dietary behavior change, and
psychological adjustment. Motivation and Emotion, 28,
245–277.
https://doi.org/10.1023/B:MOEM.0000040154.40922.14
Roberts, D. S. L. (2017). Diet preference and decision-making:
short-term vs. long-term perspectives. Unpublished study.
Smith, P. J.,
Blumenthal, J. A., Babyak, M. A., et al. (2010). Effects of the dietary
approaches to stop hypertension diet, exercise, and caloric restriction
on neurocognition in overweight adults with high blood pressure.
Hypertension, 55(6),
1331-8.
DOI:
10.1161/HYPERTENSIONAHA.109.146795
Sarris, J., Logan, A. C., Akbaraly, T. N., et al. (2015). International
Society for Nutritional Psychiatry Research. Nutritional medicine as
mainstream in psychiatry. Lancet Psychiatry. 2(3):271-4.
doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366(14)00051-0
Stahre, L., Tärnell, B., Håkanson, C. E., & Hällström. T. (2007).
A randomized controlled trial of two weight-reducing short-term group
treatment programs for obesity with an 18—month follow—up.
International Journal of Behavoral Medicine, 14, 48–55.
https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02999227
Strang,
S.,
Hoeber,
C, Uhl, O.,
Koletzko,
B.,
Münte,
T. F.,
Lehnert,
H.,
Dolan,
R. J.,
Schmid,
S. M., &
Park,
S. Q. (2017). Impact of nutrition on social decision-making.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Science of the USA, 114(25):6510-6514.
https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.162024511
Thomas, F. N., Burnette,
J. L., & Hoy, C. L. (2019). Mindsets of health and healthy eating
intentions, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 19(6), 372-380.
https://doi.org/10.1111/jasp.12589
Tindle, H. A., Chang, Y. F., Kuller, L. H., et al.,(2009). Optimism,
cynical hostility, and incident coronary heart disease and mortality in
the Women's Health Initiative. Circulation, 120(8):656-62.
DOI:
10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.108.827642
Tribole, E., & Resch, E. (2017). Intuitive eating workbook:
Principles for nourishing a healthy relationship with food. New
Harbinger Publications, Inc.
Warren, J. M., Smith, N., & Ashwell, M. (2017.
A structured
literature review on the role of mindfulness, mindful eating and
intuitive eating in changing eating behaviours: effectiveness and
associated potential mechanisms. Nutrition Research Review, 30(2),
272-283. DOI:10.1017/S0954422417000154
Werthmann, J., Jansen, A., & Roefs, A. (2016). Make up your mind about
food: A healthy mindset attenuates attention for high-calorie food in
restrained eaters. Appetite, 195(1), 53-59.
DOI:10.1016/j.appet.2016.05.005
Further Readings
Branch, R., & Willson, R. C(2010). Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for
dummies
(2nd Edition). John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Greenberger D., & Padesky, C. A. (1995)). Mind over mood; Change how
you feel by changing the way you think. The Guilford Press.
Tsui,
V. (2018). The mindful eating workbook: Simple mindfulness practices
to nurture a healthy relationship with food. New Harbinger
Publications.
Waldinger, R., & Schulz, M. (2023). The good life: Lessons from the
world’s longer scientific study of happiness. Simon & Schuster, Inc.
|